Defending Japan

Offshore in a Dangerous Neighbourhood

Posts Tagged ‘Intelligence

Wikileaks on Japanese-US-Australian intelligence cooperation

leave a comment »

Prime Minister Shinzo Abe with President George W. Bush and Prime Minister John Howard in Sydney, September 8 2007
Prime Minister Shinzo Abe with President George W. Bush
and Prime Minister John Howard in Sydney, September 8 2007
(Source: MOFA)

This one was a bit of a surprise earlier in the week, but it offers useful insight into what Japan’s poor data OPSEC has done to its reputation.

In 2006, as Japan and Australia were discussing what would become the March 2007 Japan-Australia Joint Declaration on Security Cooperation, Australia and the US discussed Japanese proposals of a greater intelligence exchange relationship on regional issues, including rising China, North Korea, and Iran.

This particular passage was deeply telling:

In a meeting with senior Japanese Foreign Ministry intelligence officials, [Randall Fort, head of the US State Department Intelligence and Research Bureau] urged his counterparts to tap the ”underutilised assets” represented by the global network of Japanese businesses.

”Japan, with its economic and diplomatic presence in countries like Iran, could draw on insights that would be of great interest to the United States,”

Japan had a ”unique opportunity” to collect intelligence inside Iran where the US had no embassy, he argued.

”Any diplomatic or intelligence reporting Japan received from Iran, no matter how seemingly mundane, would be extremely valuable to us.”

However, Japan’s poor control over its information security left the US and Australia cold (this was a time when the MSDF were losing data to Chinese honeytraps and computer file-sharers). Indeed, Japan’s lax security are often blamed for Chinese military developments by security otaku in Japan.

It is unclear to what extent this intelligence exchange grew and how well it survived Prime Minister Shinzo Abe (assuming it was his initiative – he showed interest in bilateral security exchanges and the beefing up of Japanese intelligence).


Written by James

2011/01/23 at 00:03

Defense Ministry considering UAV option

leave a comment »

The Northrop Grumman RQ-4 Global Hawk
Northrop Grumman RQ-4 Global Hawk via Wikipedia

On December 30, the Daily Yomiuri reported that Japan is looking into UAV technology for the surveillance of China and North Korea. This is backed up by the Midterm Defense Buildup Program from 2011, which the Cabinet approved on December 17. The paper’s sources in Ichigaya stated that senior SDF officers will look at the US experience with the Global Hawk, Northrop Grumman‘s long-range high-altitude drone. This would be a departure from previous research since 2003 into a domestically produced capability.

The US has flown the Global Hawk in both Iraq and Afghanistan. With a range of over 16,000 km and 18,000 metre ceiling, it can stay in the air for over 30 hours and gather strategic and tactical IMINT in a 550 km radius without putting its operator in danger. Although there has been some concern over the cost efficacy of the Global Hawk procurement programme in the US, at first glance it would appear to be a great choice for the JSDF as they face the current instability on the Korean Peninsula and rising China.

The Yomiuri article suggests that they would be used for territorial overwatch, stating that “three reconnaissance drones would be necessary to cover all of Japan’s territory and surrounding waters.” That would be at a unit cost of about ¥7.5 billion, plus the cost of the infrastructure. The article also mentions concerns over subsequent personnel cuts, although these officials don’t have to worry. A UAV fleet would be unlikely to replace the current 100-bird strong MSDF P-3C reconnaissance fleet in the short term. The Global Hawk will be a valuable strategic tool, but it is unlikely that it will mothball its manned counterpart after the Ministry spent so much money putting them into service. Just look at how many Type 74 tanks are still service in the GSDF.

A Kyodo report gives possible operational scenarios for the Global Hawk, “to defend remote Japanese islands and counter suspicious ships in and near Japanese waters, while at the same time looking at the possibility of operating them as part of the country’s shield against ballistic missiles”. This kind of territorial security mission would be a cakewalk for the Global Hawk, but if Japan is looking to keep an eye on China and North Korea, as the Yomiuri article hints at, then Japan would be much better off improving its spaceborne IMINT capabilities (namely the Information Gathering Satellite constellation).

If the Defense Ministry can pin down just what it wants a long-range UAV to be capable of, and use the capability in tandem with the current P-3C fleet, they will be able to constantly monitor Japanese territorial waters. That seems to be a realistic aim, but a couple of questions remain: Is it possible within the current budget, and who would fly them?

Enhanced by Zemanta

Written by James

2011/01/07 at 22:00